Which Prue Is It Anyway?

When Phoebe has a premonition of Prue being stabbed to death, it coincides with a warrior coming to town in order to kill the eldest sibling witch as he did to the sisters' great-great-great-aunt.

Season 1 | Episode 16
Cast

Alyssa Milano

as Phoebe Halliwell

Rose McGowan

as Paige Matthews

Holly Marie Combs

as Piper Halliwell

Shannen Doherty

as Prue Halliwell

Brian Krause

as Leo Wyatt

Julian McMahon

as Cole Turner